Tilly's Pies

If you’re searching for a slice of heaven in the charming town of Cable, Wisconsin, look no further than Tilly's Pies. This delightful café, nestled at 43433 Kavanaugh Rd, has garnered a reputation for being a pie lover's paradise, where each bite tells a story of love, dedication, and beautifully crafted flavors. Call them at +1 715-798-3108 for inquiries or to place your orders!

At Tilly's, the star of the show is undeniably the pies, each crafted from time-tested recipes and the finest ingredients. Imagine sinking your fork into the luscious layers of a strawberry rhubarb pie that balances sweet and tart perfectly, as echoed in Eric Elmquist’s enthusiastic review: 'The strawberry rhubarb pie was incredible.' Or take a trip back to your childhood with the nostalgic banana cream pie, as Mike Hall describes savoring its creamy, rich texture paired with delightful crust and topping.

This café doesn't just stop at serving delicious pies. It elevates the experience by providing a cozy, inviting atmosphere where you can relax and engage with locals. As Jim Mac notes, "a welcoming place to hang out and enjoy the locals," Tilly’s becomes more than just a stop for dessert; it’s a cherished gathering spot. Whether you’re relishing a slice with a cup of world-class coffee or engaging in delightful conversation with Trudi, the passionate owner, you will feel at home in this charming café.

For those who can't get enough, many patrons, like Rebecca Recks, find themselves returning multiple times a week: 'We loved these pies so much we went 3 times this week!' Each visit allows you to sample different flavors—there's good reason folks make the journey from hours away, as captured by Marcos Lasanta: 'By far, the best pies of my life! We travel over 6 hours just to get a piece of pie and coffee.'

If you’re adventurous and looking to try an array of flavors, take a cue from Ryan Seefeldt, who enjoyed both the Four Berry Pie and Key Lime. Each bite reflects the quality and care that goes into every pie, setting Tilly's apart from typical dessert stops.

Whether you’re a local or passing through on a road trip, Tilly's Pies is a culinary gem that should be on your itinerary. With vibrant flavors, a warm atmosphere, and friendly service, it promises a truly unforgettable experience that will leave you dreaming of your next visit. So why not plan a trip to Cable, and make Tilly's Pies a must-stop destination on your journey?